Google Reviews
We’re a Teen Residential Treatment Facility in Arizona & Idaho, offering support for teens and resources to help parents navigate their child’s challenges.
When your child’s social struggles don’t neatly fit one box, you’re left with a specific, gnawing fear: What if we get the diagnosis wrong? Trying to match behaviors to online checklists only deepens the confusion, because the answer isn’t in the social challenges they share—it’s in the one core behavior they don’t. This guide provides a clear, side-by-side comparison of social (pragmatic) communication disorder and autism, focusing on the single diagnostic factor that distinguishes them.
Jump to a section
Key takeaways
- Shared challenge: Both social communication disorder (SCD) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) involve significant difficulties with social communication.
- The key difference: The presence of restricted interests and repetitive behaviors is required for an Autism diagnosis, but is absent in SCD.
- No double diagnosis: A person cannot be diagnosed with both SCD and Autism; the presence of repetitive behaviors automatically points to Autism.
- Expert evaluation is crucial: An accurate diagnosis requires a multidisciplinary team, often led by a speech-language pathologist and a psychologist.
- Support is available: Regardless of the diagnosis, speech therapy and social skills training can help your child thrive.
What is social (pragmatic) communication disorder (SCD)?
Social (pragmatic) communication disorder (SCD) is a diagnosis for persistent difficulty with the social rules of communication—both verbal and nonverbal. Think of it as struggling with the unwritten rules of conversation that many people pick up naturally. According to the diagnostic criteria, this involves challenges in all of the following areas:
- Using language for social purposes: This includes difficulty with things like greeting others, sharing information, and asking relevant questions in a way that fits the situation.
- Changing communication for the context: A child may struggle to adjust their way of speaking for different listeners or settings, like using the same formal tone with a friend as they would with a teacher.
- Following conversational rules: This can look like taking turns in a conversation, rephrasing when misunderstood, or knowing how to use signals to start or end a discussion.
- Understanding non-literal language: Difficulties understanding non-literal or ambiguous language meanings are common, making it hard to grasp sarcasm, humor, idioms, or metaphors.
Examples of SCD in everyday situations
When you translate the clinical criteria into daily life, these challenges become more recognizable. A child with SCD might consistently find themselves in socially confusing or awkward situations. Here is what that can look like:
- Telling disjointed stories: They may struggle to tell a story in a logical order, often leaving out important details or including irrelevant ones, which makes it difficult for others to follow.
- Misreading social cues: They might not notice when a friend is bored, in a hurry, or upset, and continue talking without adjusting their tone to match the other person’s nonverbal signals.
- Dominating conversations: A child may talk at length about their own interests without giving others a chance to speak or asking about their experiences.
- Being overly literal: If you say, “It’s raining cats and dogs,” they might look outside for animals instead of understanding the expression.
Is SCD considered a neurodivergent condition?
The term “neurodiversity” suggests that brain differences like autism are natural variations, not deficits to be cured. While autism is increasingly viewed through a neurodiversity lens, the position of SCD is still developing within this framework.
Because the diagnosis is relatively new and more narrowly focused on communication, it is not yet as well-established within the neurodiversity spectrum. However, any approach to treatment should respect a child’s individual differences and identity.
A brief history of the SCD diagnosis
Understanding the origins of SCD helps clarify what it is. The diagnosis was officially introduced in 2013 with the publication of the DSM-5.
It was created in part to provide a more accurate diagnosis for individuals who have significant social communication challenges but do not have the restricted interests or repetitive behaviors required for an autism diagnosis.
Before the DSM-5, many of these individuals might have been diagnosed with Pervasive Developmental Disorder-Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS), a category that no longer exists. SCD was introduced to bridge this diagnostic gap.
What is autism spectrum disorder (ASD)?
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is defined by the presence of challenges in two distinct and equally important areas. For a diagnosis to be made, a child must show persistent deficits in both core domains:
- Restricted and repetitive patterns of behavior: This second, crucial domain is the key differentiator from SCD. It includes stereotyped movements, an intense need for routine, highly focused interests, and sensory sensitivities.
- Social communication and interaction challenges: This domain includes difficulties with the back-and-forth of conversation, understanding nonverbal cues like body language, and developing and maintaining relationships.
Understanding the “spectrum” in ASD
It is essential to understand that the word “spectrum” does not imply a simple linear progression from “less autistic” to “more autistic.” Instead, think of it like a sound mixing board, where each person has a unique combination of traits with different “volume” levels.
One person might have profound sensory sensitivities but strong verbal skills. Another might be nonverbal and communicate with a device, yet have only mild repetitive behaviors.
The spectrum honors the reality that autism encompasses varying levels of symptom severity and support needs, creating a unique profile of strengths and challenges for every individual.
SCD vs. Autism: A side-by-side comparison
The confusion between SCD and Autism often comes from their overlapping social challenges; seeing them side-by-side makes the dividing line clear.
| Characteristic | Social (pragmatic) communication disorder (SCD) | Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) |
| Social communication | This is the primary and sole area of challenge. Includes difficulty with conversation, understanding non-literal language, and adjusting communication to the context. | Significant challenges are present, but they are one of two core diagnostic domains. |
| Behavioral patterns | Absent. Restricted interests and repetitive behaviors are not part of an SCD diagnosis. This is the key distinction. | Present and required for diagnosis. Includes repetitive movements (stimming), insistence on sameness, and highly focused interests. |
| Sensory issues | Not a core diagnostic criterion. While a child could have sensory issues, they are not a defining feature of SCD itself. | A core diagnostic criterion. Includes over- or under-reactivity to sensory input, such as sounds, textures, or lights. |
| Core diagnostic criteria | Persistent difficulties in the social use of verbal and nonverbal communication ONLY. | Persistent deficits in BOTH social communication AND the presence of restricted, repetitive behaviors. |
The deciding factor: Restricted and repetitive behaviors in autism
While social struggles create the initial question, the presence of restricted and repetitive behaviors (RRBs) provides the definitive answer. This is the diagnostic bright line.
These behaviors are not random; they are often a person’s way of navigating a world that can feel overwhelming and unpredictable.
Examples of repetitive motor movements (stimming)
These movements, often called “stimming,” are one of the most visible signs of autism and serve as a way to self-regulate emotions like excitement, anxiety, or boredom. Stimming can take many forms, including:
- Body movements: This is what most people picture, such as hand-flapping, finger-flicking, rocking back and forth, or spinning.
- Use of objects: A child might repetitively line up toys, spin the wheels on a car, or flick a light switch on and off.
- Vocal stimming: This includes the stereotyped or repetitive motor movements, use of objects, or speech, like repeating specific phrases (echolalia) or making humming sounds.
Insistence on sameness and inflexible routines
For many autistic individuals, predictability is a powerful tool for managing anxiety. A structured routine acts as a safe harbor in a world that can feel chaotic and confusing. This need for sameness can appear as:
- Rigid daily schedules: A child might insist on eating the same food for breakfast, watching the same show, or following the same steps to get ready for bed each night.
- Difficulty with transitions: The intense distress over a small change—like taking a different route to the store—is not defiance. It’s a reaction to a broken routine, as any deviation from established routines can feel uncomfortable or distressing.
- Ritualistic behaviors: This might look like needing to touch every doorknob on the way out of the house or arranging objects in a specific, unchanging order.
Highly restricted, intense interests
While many children have hobbies, the interests of an autistic child are often notable for their powerful intensity and narrow focus. These passions can become areas of incredible expertise and joy. This trait often looks like:
- Deep, specialized knowledge: A child may learn everything there is to know about a specific topic, like the entire subway system, a particular species of dinosaur, or a video game’s world.
- Focus that excludes other activities: The interest can be so all-consuming that it’s difficult for the child to engage in other activities or conversations.
- A bridge for connection: When embraced, these passions are more than a symptom; they can serve as powerful motivators and a unique way to connect with your child on their terms.
Sensory sensitivities (hyper- or hypo-reactivity)
Many people with autism experience the sensory world differently. Their brains may amplify certain sensory inputs while dampening others, leading to a constant balancing act. This involves either over-sensitivity (hypersensitivity) or under-sensitivity (hyposensitivity) to stimuli:
- Hyper-sensitivity (over-responsive): This is when ordinary sights, sounds, or textures can feel painful or overwhelming. It’s the hum of fluorescent lights that feels deafening or a clothing tag that feels like sandpaper.
- Hypo-sensitivity (under-responsive): This is a need for more intense sensory input. It can look like a high tolerance for pain, a constant need to touch objects and people, or a love for crashing into furniture and spinning.
The diagnostic process: How to get an accurate evaluation
Knowing the difference between SCD and Autism is one thing; getting the right diagnosis for your child is another. This process can feel intimidating, but it’s a structured journey designed to bring clarity.
Why an accurate differential diagnosis is crucial
It’s natural to worry about labels, but an accurate diagnosis is not a label—it’s a roadmap. It points your family toward the right support, tailored to your child’s specific needs, and helps you avoid years of frustration. Getting the diagnosis right is critical for several reasons:
- Ensuring the right therapy: An accurate diagnosis ensures your child receives interventions designed for their specific challenges, rather than a generic approach that may not be effective.
- Preventing future complications: Misdiagnosis leads to inappropriate treatments and can delay access to the specialized support that helps a child build skills and confidence, reducing the risk of secondary mental health issues.
- Opening access to support: A correct diagnosis is often the key to unlocking services at school, such as an Individualized Education Program (IEP), and qualifying for insurance coverage for therapies.
The central role of the Speech-Language Pathologist (SLP)
When the core question is about social communication, the Speech-Language Pathologist (SLP) is often the central figure in the investigation. They are experts in both typical and atypical language development. An SLP’s evaluation is essential because they:
- Assess pragmatic skills: They use specialized tools and observation to formally evaluate your child’s ability to use and understand social language in different contexts.
- Rule out other factors: They can help determine if other issues, like a language disorder or hearing loss, are contributing to the communication challenges.
- Differentiate between disorders: Their expertise in language development positions them uniquely to evaluate and treat social communication difficulties and distinguish the patterns of SCD from those seen in Autism.
Building a multidisciplinary assessment team
A single professional sees one part of the picture. A comprehensive diagnostic team assesses the whole child, combining various areas of expertise to ensure that nothing is overlooked.
This team-based approach is considered the gold standard for evaluation. While the members can vary, a comprehensive team often includes:
- A clinical psychologist or neuropsychologist: To assess cognitive skills, behavior, and emotional functioning.
- A developmental-behavioral pediatrician: A doctor who specializes in the development and behavior of children.
- An occupational therapist: To evaluate sensory processing and daily living skills.
- The SLP: To provide an in-depth analysis of social and pragmatic communication.
What to expect during a diagnostic evaluation
The goal of an evaluation is not to “test” your child in a stressful way, but to understand their unique way of thinking, playing, and communicating. The process is designed to gather information from multiple sources. A comprehensive evaluation typically involves:
- Detailed parent interviews: You are the expert on your child. The evaluation will start with in-depth conversations about your child’s developmental history, strengths, and challenges.
- Direct observation: The clinician will interact with your child through play-based activities to observe their communication, social interaction, and behavior in a natural setting.
- Standardized assessments: These may include structured tests, checklists, and questionnaires for both you and your child’s teachers to complete. A thorough evaluation should include interviews with parents, teachers, and other adults who know the child well.
Can a person have both SCD and autism?
This is one of the most common and important questions parents ask. The short answer is no. The DSM-5, the manual used for diagnosis, establishes a rule of mutual exclusivity. This means that a diagnosis of SCD cannot be made if ASD is also present. This rule was created to prevent diagnostic confusion and ensure that individuals with very similar symptoms should not receive different diagnoses that lead to different types of support. It provides a clear path for clinicians to follow.
What a diagnosis of SCD means for autism
Think of it this way: the presence of restricted and repetitive behaviors is the deciding factor that automatically points to a diagnosis of autism. If a comprehensive evaluation finds that a child has both social communication challenges AND restricted/repetitive behaviors, the correct diagnosis is autism spectrum disorder.
A diagnosis of social communication disorder is only considered when a child’s social communication challenges are significant. Still, a thorough evaluation confirms that the restrictive and repetitive behaviors in ASD are not found. In essence, SCD describes the communication challenges without the behavioral patterns of autism.
Treatment and support for social communication challenges
Regardless of the diagnosis, the goal is the same: to give your child the tools they need to connect with others. This work is built on a foundation of specialized therapies and practical, supportive strategies.
The foundations of speech and language therapy
Speech and language therapy is the cornerstone of support for social communication challenges, led by a highly trained professional known as a Speech-Language Pathologist (SLP). An SLP’s work involves:
- Creating a personalized plan: They assess, diagnose, and treat speech, language, social communication disorders by first understanding your child’s unique profile of strengths and needs.
- Targeting pragmatic skills: Therapy focuses directly on the practical skills of social interaction, such as taking turns in conversation, understanding humor, and reading nonverbal cues.
- Collaborating with your family: SLPs provide training and strategies for parents and caregivers to ensure the skills learned in therapy are practiced and reinforced at home and school.
The benefits of social skills training groups
While individual therapy builds foundational skills, social skills groups offer a safe, structured environment to practice them with peers in real time.
These groups provide several key advantages by:
- Offering a safe practice space: Children can try out new social skills with peers who are working on similar goals, without the fear of typical schoolyard judgment.
- Providing immediate feedback: A trained therapist facilitates the group, offering gentle coaching and guidance as interactions happen naturally.
- Improving social confidence: Group-based training helps children feel more capable in social settings.
Intervention strategies
Therapists use a variety of proven methods to make abstract social rules more concrete and understandable for children. Common strategies you might see in therapy include:
- Video modeling: Using short, simple videos that show positive examples of a target social skill, like how to join a game or ask a friend a question.
- Social stories: Creating a short, personalized story that describes a specific social situation, explains the perspectives of others, and suggests an appropriate response.
- Role-playing: Acting out different social scenarios in a low-pressure setting to practice communication skills and build confidence for real-world interactions.
The role of Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC)
For some children, especially those who are nonverbal or have limited speech, Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) is a powerful bridge to connection. It’s important to understand that:
- AAC is more than just devices: It encompasses all communication methods beyond talking, from simple gestures and picture boards to high-tech, speech-generating tablets.
- AAC supports speech development: A common concern is that AAC will hinder a child’s ability to learn to talk. In fact, research shows it can facilitate rather than hinder speech development.
- AAC gives your child a voice: Most importantly, it provides a reliable way for your child to express their thoughts, needs, and feelings, reducing frustration and increasing their ability to participate in the world.
Practical strategies for supporting a child at home and school
Therapy provides the tools, but it’s your home and school where the real practice takes place. The small, consistent supports you build into daily life create the foundation for your child’s growth and confidence.
Creating a supportive and predictable home environment
For a child working hard to decode social cues, a predictable home environment isn’t about control—it’s a quiet place for their brain to rest and recharge. Consistency reduces the cognitive load of navigating an unpredictable world. You can create this sense of safety by:
- Establishing consistent daily routines: Maintaining structured routines for mornings, homework, and bedtime reduces daily negotiation and the anxiety that comes with uncertainty.
- Creating a sensory-friendly space: A designated calm-down corner with dim lighting, soft blankets, or noise-canceling headphones can help a child decompress when they feel overwhelmed.
- Using clear and direct language: Simple, concrete language that avoids sarcasm, idioms, or vague instructions helps prevent misunderstandings and reduces the mental effort needed to communicate.
Effective collaboration with teachers and school staff
You are the expert on your child, and the school staff are the education experts. Building a strong partnership turns advocacy from a battle into a collaboration, ensuring your child is supported consistently across their day. Strengthen your home-school partnership by:
- Scheduling regular, brief check-ins: A weekly email or a shared communication notebook helps create a consistent flow of information and allows you to address small issues before they become big ones.
- Focusing on shared goals: Work with the teacher to identify one or two key social goals to focus on. This ensures everyone is working together to support your child’s progress in a targeted way.
- Keeping a simple communication log: Note which strategies are working, any new challenges you encounter, and any questions you have. This makes conversations with the school more focused and productive.
Using visual supports and social stories
Many children with social communication challenges are strong visual thinkers. Visual supports and social stories translate abstract social rules into a concrete, easy-to-follow format they can understand and refer back to. Consider implementing these simple tools:
- A visual schedule: A simple chart with pictures or words that outlines the day’s events. This shows your child what is happening next, which can dramatically reduce anxiety around transitions.
- A “First-Then” board: This basic two-panel board shows a clear sequence (e.g., “First homework, Then tablet”). It’s a powerful tool for motivating your child to complete a less-preferred task.
- Personalized social stories: A short, simple story that describes a specific situation, like going to a birthday party, and models appropriate social responses and what to expect.
FAQs about SCD and autism in teens
Hope for your family
The journey to a diagnosis is not about finding a label that fits; it’s about finding a diagnosis that fits. It’s about finding a lens that finally helps you see your child clearly. This new understanding is the actual roadmap, allowing you to stop searching for a fix and start building a world that fits them.
Care at Avery’s House
For teens with Autism or SCD, co-occurring mental health challenges like anxiety or depression can make daily life feel impossible. Avery’s House provides a specialized residential setting where your teen can receive integrated, 24/7 support to manage both their neurodivergent needs and mental health, helping them build the skills to thrive.
- Learn about our Residential Program
- Contact our admissions team
Sources
- American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.). https://iacc.hhs.gov/about-iacc/subcommittees/resources/dsm5-diagnostic-criteria.shtml
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. (2024). Augmentative and alternative communication. ASHA. https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/professional-issues/augmentative-and-alternative-communication/
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. (2024). Social communication disorder. ASHA. https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/clinical-topics/social-communication-disorder/
- American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. (2024). Speech-language pathologists. ASHA. https://www.asha.org/students/speech-language-pathologists/
- Brukner-Wertman, Y., Laor, N., & Golan, O. (2021). The DSM-5 introduction of the Social (Pragmatic) Communication Disorder as a new mental disorder: a philosophical review. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience, 271(6), 1007–1017. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8463351/
- Brukner-Wertman, Y., Laor, N., & Golan, O. (2021). The DSM-5 introduction of Social (Pragmatic) Communication Disorder as a new mental disorder: A philosophical review. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 43(4), 118. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40656-021-00460-0
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2024). Clinical testing and diagnosis for autism spectrum disorder. CDC. https://www.cdc.gov/autism/hcp/diagnosis/index.html
- Child Mind Institute. (2024). Autism and stimming. https://childmind.org/article/autism-and-stimming/
- Child Mind Institute. (2024). Complete guide to autism. https://childmind.org/guide/parents-guide-to-autism/
- Child Mind Institute. (2024). Sensory processing issues explained. https://childmind.org/article/sensory-processing-issues-explained/
- Dubreucq, J., Haesebaert, F., Plasse, J., Dubreucq, M., & Franck, N. (2022). A systematic review and meta-analysis of social skills training for adults with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 52(4), 1598–1609. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10803-021-05058-w
- Fusar-Poli, L., Brondino, N., Politi, P., & Aguglia, E. (2022). Missed diagnoses and misdiagnoses of adults with autism spectrum disorder. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience, 272(6), 995-1006. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00406-020-01189-w
- Partners in School Research Group. (2021). Partners in school: Optimizing communication between parents and teachers of children with autism spectrum disorder. School Psychology Review, 50(2-3), 321–335. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8694006/
- Pellicano, E. (2022). Annual research review: Shifting from ‘normal science’ to neurodiversity in autism science. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 63(4), 381–396. https://acamh.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jcpp.13534
- Seattle Children’s Autism Center. (2018). Interdisciplinary team evaluation: An effective method for the diagnostic assessment of autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 48(6), 1967–1976. https://wmich.edu/wecan/enrollment/assessments